One Argument: The Scientist vs. The Priest.

A scientist and a Priest have an argument. They summon me to bear witness to their argumentation.

The Scientist claims that Science is Perfect. It is the only way to True Knowledge. The Priest, on the other hand, also claims that his God is Perfect. And that this God is the only True Way to Knowledge.

After their statements, I said “fair enough.” I agreed with them. But they looked stupefied.

So I asked them. Which one of you then is Perfect? The scientist and the priest agree that they were not Perfect.

So I asked them a simple common sense question: If you extrude a Perfect Thing through an Imperfect Vessel (you), do you obtain a Perfect Product or an Imperfect Product?

An imperfect product. They agreed!

You see, it doesn’t matter how Perfect a thing may be in theory, but it is actually the Vessel that carries the thing that matters on Earth (in reality), in practice. The question is never about which one is Perfect, or which one is more Perfect – God or Science; Religion or Science.

Note: (On the Brutish Broadcasting Company: A metallurgist in the US state of Washington has pleaded guilty to fraud after she spent decades faking the results of strength tests on steel that was being used to make Navy submarines.) The Tests (in theory) were scientific, i.e. Perfect, but the Vessel (the scientist) was a thief.

Previous articleThe Metha: “Party Like Savages.”
Next articleThe Metha: His Soccer, His Manchester United.
Amenuti Narmer
"Success without usefulness is a dangerous mentor. It seduces the ignorant into believing he cannot lose, and it misleads the intellectual into thinking he must always win. Success corrupts; only usefulness exalts." — WP. Narmer Amenuti (whose name translates to Dances With Lions) was born by the river, deep within the heartlands of Ghana, in Ntoaboma. A public intellectual from the Sankoré School of Critical Theory, he was trained and awarded the highest honor of Warrior Philosopher at the Temple of Narmer. As a cultural critic and a Guan rhythmmaker, Amenuti is a dilettante, a dissident, and a gadfly. He eschews promotional intellectualism and maintains strict anonymity, inviting both scholars and laypeople into open and honest debate. He reads every comment. If you enjoyed this essay and wish to support more work like it, pour libation to the Ancestors in support of the next piece—or go bold, very bold, and invoke them. Here's my CashApp: $TheRealNarmer

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.